Federal Justice of the Peace Choose Kyle Dudek just lately issued the next Order: 1
As a result of the events haven’t agreed on an umpire, the Court docket will set an in-person listening to for the appraisers to seem together with counsel to advise the Court docket of their respective objections to their counterpart’s proposed umpires. The Court docket will set this listening to by separate discover. If the appraisers agree on an umpire earlier than the listening to, the events should file a discover and the listening to shall be cancelled. The events also needs to be ready to debate Defendant’s arguments concerning the type of the award on the listening to.
Let’s put you, our readers, within the scorching seat—think about you’re the decide and even an appraiser on this situation. Who would you choose? How would you make your resolution? Ought to the decide name for the appraisers to point out up in particular person on the listening to?
Now flip the script: in case you have been an appraiser, would you be apprehensive if the decide requested whether or not the occasion who appointed you gave you an inventory of “accepted umpires”? And in case you have been the decide, would you are feeling much less inclined to choose somebody instructed by the events concerned?
Selections, choices—what would you do?
It might be the appraisers or events will observe my recommendation in “New York Appraisal—Can a Federal Choose Select the Umpire” and agree:
After which there’s the judicial wild card. If each events to the contract can’t agree on an umpire, a decide takes over the reins. Right here’s the place issues get much more unpredictable. Having been within the trenches, I can inform you that there’s no guidebook for predicting or understanding how a decide will method the duty of umpire choice. Will they prioritize trade expertise, an even-tempered disposition, or one thing else altogether? Your guess is pretty much as good as mine.
Due to this uncertainty, my recommendation to appraisers and events has remained steadfast for over a decade: try to search out widespread floor in choosing an umpire you each can belief. In different phrases, “Stick with the Satan You Know.” Why roll the cube with a judicially appointed umpire when the satan you’ve collectively chosen is—at the least—one whose temperament and integrity you each have had a say in?
Right here is the submitting by the insurance coverage firm:
Right here is the submitting by the policyholder:
Thought For The Day
If you come to a fork within the street, take it.
—Yogi Berra
1 Nice Hill Christian Church Ministries v. Ohio Safety Ins. Co., No. 2:24-cv-417 (M.D, Fla. Nov. 18, 2024).
