Whenever you buy by hyperlinks on our web site, we could earn a fee. Right here’s the way it works.
House owners of huge canine with thick and lengthy fur have a tough time discovering a shock collar that’s efficient. Why? All that further hair. Additionally generally referred to as e-collars or distant coaching collars, shock collars are solely efficient when the contact factors (prongs) can attain by the fur to make contact with a canine’s pores and skin to ship the suitable correction stimulation, whether or not that be by vibration solely or static shock. Many coaching e-collars don’t provide the options you want in case your pup is tremendous furry, however relaxation assured, I’ve discovered a few of your finest choices.
When Can I Begin Utilizing A Shock Coaching Collar?
Most specialists suggest ready to make use of a shock collar till a canine is a minimum of six months outdated. It’s essential to make sure that your pup has a stable grasp of primary instructions. In the event that they haven’t mastered these fundamentals, utilizing a shock collar might really result in extra behavioral points. It’s at all times a good suggestion to discuss to a veterinarian or skilled canine coach about your considerations and coaching targets earlier than beginning with a coaching collar.
You may additionally wish to think about using an on-line coaching course together with an e-collar. DIYK9 has a incredible course taught by a licensed police canine coach. “Unleashed! 5 Steps To E-Collar Mastery” is all about optimistic reinforcement coaching and never fear-based coaching — an enormous concern about shock collar use.
Elements To Think about
When searching for a shock collar for canine with lengthy hair and thick coats, you’ll want to contemplate a number of options to search out the very best match in your further furry pal. Right here’s what I like to recommend.
- Contact level (prong) size: E-collars that include longer shock collar prongs for lengthy hair are important for canine with lengthy, thick fur or a double coat, as these contact factors can extra successfully entry the canine’s pores and skin.
- Collar dimension & sturdiness: Clearly, giant canine want longer collar sizes. Additionally, in case your pup is a leash puller or tends to chew their collar, you’ll must search for shock collars that match these wants.
- Correction sorts: Most e-collars have a number of correction sorts which you could modify in your pup’s wants. These embrace beep, vibration, and static shock choices. Collars differ broadly within the ranges you may attain with every correction kind.
- Collar sensitivity: Some bigger and extra cussed canine may have a better degree of depth for vibration and static corrections.
- Value: For house owners on a finances, collar worth is an enormous issue. Nevertheless, the identical holds true for many merchandise — the cheaper they’re, the much less dependable and sturdy. I researched dozens of bestselling low cost shock collars (these below $50), and many purchasers say they’re not value it. That’s why I don’t embrace these in my high selections.
Finest Shock Collars For Massive Canine With Thick Fur
I’ve extensively researched shock collars for all sorts of canine and selected my high picks primarily based on high quality and efficiency, prong and collar dimension, correction modes and ranges, pricing, buyer suggestions, and extra.
Finest Worth: Pet Resolve PTS-1200 Coaching Collar Evaluation
The Pet Resolve Coaching Collar is a superb worth for the vary and options it gives. It comes with three units of prongs — the biggest are almost an inch lengthy — and has a 3/4 mile vary, LED night time mode (with totally different colours for every canine), anti-bark mode, detachable prongs, sturdy collar, low battery indicator, and different cool options.
This e-collar has beep, vibration (10 ranges), and 10 ranges of momentary or steady shock modes. The transmitter and receiver are waterproof. The collar is produced from thermoplastic polyurethane, which will be lower to dimension, and has a sturdy steel buckle. A overwhelming majority of consumers rave about this coaching system and say it’s dependable and of top of the range.
| Execs | Cons |
|---|---|
| Incredible worth | Has fewer ranges of correction than another collars |
| 3 units of contact factors included (largest are 4/5″) | A number of complaints that the distant stops working after a number of months of steady use |
| Collar size as much as 27-1/2″ | |
| As much as 3/4 mile vary | |
| Battery life as much as 3 days | |
| Expandable to three canine | |
| 1-year guarantee | |
| Customers report excellent customer support |
Value
Finest Premium: Garmin Sport PRO Bundle Evaluation
View on Amazon | View on Chewy
Garmin is a extremely trusted model amongst canine trainers, house owners of working canine, and different specialists, and this Sport Professional coaching collar is one in all its bestsellers for all sorts of canine. It has 4 coaching buttons for steady and momentary stimulation, vibration, and tone, and setting the depth degree is a breeze.
One cool characteristic is its BarkLimiter with adjustables ranges to curb undesirable barking. The distant and collar are each waterproof, and the receiver additionally has LED beacon lights which can be seen as much as 100 yards away in low gentle circumstances. In case you can afford this higher-priced system, it’s value it for the reliablity, superior high quality, and long-lasting product life.
| Execs | Cons |
|---|---|
| Excellent efficiency | On the expensive facet |
| Comes with lengthy 3/4″ contact factors | Has fewer ranges of correction (10) than another collars |
| Collar size as much as 27″ | A number of complaints that the audible tone isn’t loud sufficient |
| As much as 3/4 mile vary | |
| Battery life as much as 60 hours | |
| Expandable to three canine | |
| 1-year guarantee |
Value
Finest For Further Massive & Large Breeds: Dogtra 1900S Evaluation
View on Amazon | View on Chewy
Like Garmin, Dogtra is an organization that has a protracted observe document of manufacturing top-notch, high-performing coaching collars. The Dogtra 1900S isn’t any exception and a incredible selection for giant canine with heavy coats. It has larger depth correction ranges than the Garmin Sport Professional (and different collars I overview right here), which will be helpful for very giant and/or cussed canine. Plus, you may improve this collar with one-inch prongs or Titanium Flexi Fin contact factors (a lot buy individually). The collar is longer and wider than many others and has a heavy-duty steel buckle.
This method comes with low-to-high nick (fast 1/2 second), fixed (as much as 12 seconds), and vibration corrections (no tone mode) and is IPX9K licensed waterproof. It additionally comes with a helpful belt clip for the distant. Try the Dogtra 1900X mannequin that features all of the options of the 1900S plus larger output correction, a tone mode, and LED receiver gentle.
| Execs | Cons |
|---|---|
| Highly effective collar for giant, cussed canine | On the expensive facet |
| Collar size as much as 28″ and 1″ width | Doesn’t have audible tone correction mode or LED receiver gentle |
| Vary as much as 3/4 mile | Solely comes with 5/8″ contact factors (however should buy 3/4″ and 1″ prongs individually) |
| Options 127 correction ranges (vibration and static shock) | A number of complaints that it stopped working after a number of months |
| Battery life as much as 3 days | |
| Expandable to 2 canine | |
| 1-year guarantee |
Value
What About SpotOn GPS Fence, Mini-Educator & INVIROX Collars?
These best-selling shock collars didn’t make my high picks, however they’re actually value consideration, whether or not you’re in search of a budget-friendly possibility or a digital fencing resolution. In any case, each pup proprietor has totally different wants.
INVIROX 2025 Version Shock Collar For Massive Canine Evaluation
On the lookout for a dependable shock collar for long-haired canine or these with double coats that received’t break the financial institution? The INVIROX 2025 version shock collar may very well be your finest resolution. This budget-friendly collar comes with two units of contact factors appropriate for short- and long-haired pups.
It options 123 coaching ranges, beep (1-8), vibration (1-16), and static shock mode (1-99). The distant transmitter has a helpful wrist strap and safety keypad lock to stop unintentional corrections. The collar is IP67 waterproof, and the distant is IP65 waterproof.
In case you discover that this collar isn’t sufficient, INVIROX carries an Extremely K9 mannequin that may accommodate canine as much as 150 lbs. It has stronger depth and a 3/4-mile vary.
| Execs | Cons |
|---|---|
| Inexpensive worth | Solely appropriate for canine as much as 110 lbs |
| Comes with 5/8″ and three/4″ contact factors | Some complaints that the shock characteristic stops working after a number of months |
| Collar size as much as 27″ | Some studies of a glitchy shock button |
| Vary as much as 3,350 ft (simply over 1/2 mile) | |
| Options 123 coaching ranges (beep, vibration, and static shock) | |
| Battery life as much as 15 days | |
| Accessible in a 2-dog system | |
| 1-year guarantee |
Value
Mini-Educator ET-300 Evaluation
View on Amazon | View on Chewy
Don’t let the title “Mini” deter you from contemplating this coaching collar. The Mini-Educator is a best-selling shock collar that works properly for many giant canine with thick fur. It comes with 3/4″ contact factors and options “lock and set” stimulation ranges from 1 to 100 and a lift degree from 1 to 60 to tailor the extent to your canine’s conduct. You can even go for tone or vibration-only correction. The waterproof, light-weight collar contains a nighttime monitoring gentle to enhance visibility. For enhanced contact, you should buy the Educator CPAD-011 Winged Receiver Consolation Pad.
This collar system is simply referred to as the “Mini” due to the smaller dimension distant transmitter, which is ergonomically designed, straightforward to make use of, and may even float in water. Each the transmitter and collar have low battery indicators, they usually solely take two hours to recharge. Nevertheless, I did see a number of buyer opinions that mentioned the collars cease charging after a number of months of use.
If the Mini-Educator isn’t fairly sufficient in your wants, I encourage you to take a look at the Educator ET-400, which has a 3/4-mile vary (versus 1/2 mile), or The Boss ET-800, which is designed for bigger and extra cussed canine. The Boss has a wider collar width, a one-mile vary, and better depth correction.
| Execs | Cons |
|---|---|
| Comes with 5/8″ and three/4″ contact factors | On the expensive facet |
| Collar size as much as 30″ | A number of complaints that the collar stops charging after a number of months of use |
| Vary as much as 1/2 mile | Some studies about difficult-to-reach buyer help |
| Vibration- and tone-only modes and 100 ranges of static stimulation | |
| Battery life as much as 60 hours | |
| Expandable to 2 canine | |
| 2-year guarantee | |
| Made within the USA |
Value
SpotOn GPS Fence Evaluation
SpotOn GPS Fence is a terrific possibility if you’d like a wi-fi fencing system, GPS monitoring, and extra. Whereas it’s not an ordinary coaching collar like the remainder of these in my opinions right here, SpotOn means that you can create limitless overlapping fences to maintain your pup contained in your set boundaries. It makes use of a number of ranges of tone, vibration, and static shock modes to assist right your pup to remain in your yard. Nevertheless, it’s not the very best resolution to make use of for on a regular basis coaching wants.
Whereas a subscription isn’t obligatory, the system is proscribed and not using a plan. Whereas the fences work and not using a subscription, you’ll want one to obtain alerts that your canine has left your yard and to trace his whereabouts in actual time in your smartphone.
Our Private Expertise With SpotOn GPS Fence
We had the chance to attempt SpotOn’s collar with our Cavalier King Charles Spaniel in alternate for an trustworthy overview. The collar itself was straightforward to arrange, connect the contact factors, and modify the dimensions. After activating the collar and creating an account, you may stroll together with your canine on a leash to create your digital fence in real-time. I used to be impressed at how detailed the fence line was and the way correct the invisible fence traces have been.
When getting near the “edge,” it makes a loud beep. As you get nearer to the boundary, there’s a two-tone alert. And should you cross the boundary, the collar vibrates. There’s no subscription required for the fence suggestions, however if you’d like GSP monitoring that’s an extra month-to-month payment. In case you’re in search of a strategy to include your canine and not using a want for wires, this coaching collar is well worth the funding.
– Sadie Cornelius, Cavalier King Charles Spaniel canine father or mother, Advertising & Artistic Content material For Canine Journal
| Execs | Cons |
|---|---|
| Comes with 2 sizes of contact prongs – customers say the bigger dimension is roughly 1” | Costly |
| Can create limitless, overlapping wi-fi fences over no most dimension | Largest collar dimension is 26″ |
| Straightforward to arrange | Requires a minimal of 1/2 acre |
| Actual-time alerts and correct GPS monitoring | Should pay a month-to-month payment for monitoring characteristic to work |
| IP-67 waterproof score | |
| Battery life is 14-25 hours, relying on the mode you’re utilizing | |
| 1-year restricted guarantee | |
| 90-day money-back assure | |
| 10% low cost on multi-collar purchases |
Value
Month-to-month Subscription
The non-obligatory subscription provides you entry to SpotOn’s GPS monitoring characteristic.
- Month to Month: $9.95/month
- 1-Yr: $8.49/month (save 15%)
- 2-Years: $7.49/month (save 25%)
Coupon
Use coupon code CANINE to get $50 off your SpotOn buy by way of this hyperlink.
In Depth Evaluation of SpotOn GPS Fence
Learn our complete SpotOn GPS Fence overview to study extra about this wi-fi containment system.
How Do Shock Collars Work?
Shock collars, that are also referred to as distant canine coaching collars or e-collars, consist of some key components: a handheld transmitter, a collar receiver, and collar probes. You’ll be able to modify the transmitter to pick the kind of stimulus—whether or not it’s a tone, vibration, or static stimulation—and the depth degree. As soon as set, the transmitter sends a radio sign to the receiver in your canine’s collar, which then delivers the chosen stimulus by chrome steel probes that make contact together with your canine’s neck.
The contact factors ought to be in direct contact together with your canine’s pores and skin, not simply their fur, so it’s essential to have a collar receiver that matches snugly. It’s finest to position the collar on the higher third of the neck as a substitute of decrease down close to the chest. Remember to brush your canine to clear away any free hair across the neck space.
For canine with lengthy or double coats, you would possibly must skinny out the fur a bit to make sure the probes can join properly with the pores and skin. There’s no must shave the world; utilizing thinning shears is a good possibility. If the probes can’t make correct contact, your canine received’t obtain constant correction stimulation, which might hinder the effectiveness of coaching.
Try his video tutorial by Julie’s K9 Academy that takes you thru the steps of methods to successfully put an e-collar on with a long-haired canine. The model she’s utilizing within the tutorial is the Educator, which I reviewed above.
7 Suggestions To Keep away from Potential Shock Collar Irritation
Specialists suggest taking the next precautions when utilizing a shock collar:
- Learn your product’s directions fastidiously earlier than use to make sure the correct match
- Don’t depart the e-collar on for an prolonged size of time (now not than 8-10 hours)
- Reposition the collar in your canine’s neck each one to 2 hours
- After swimming or moist climate, take away the collar and permit the neck and collar to dry earlier than placing it again on
- Clear the contact factors commonly
- In case you discover pores and skin irritation, depart the collar off to permit air to get to the neck space
- Contact your vet if the pores and skin is exhibiting any indicators of an infection
Are Shock Collars Merciless?
Many pet house owners are postpone by the idea of shock collar coaching. Nevertheless, most fashionable shock collars are made to supply low to medium-intensity choices, permitting you to pick the depth degree that fits your canine finest. The static stimulation can really feel like a mild tingle or a extra noticeable jolt, just like the static electrical energy you would possibly expertise out of your bedsheets, however the shock shouldn’t be dangerous to your furry pal. Nonetheless, many house owners choose to solely use the tone and vibration settings on these collars, and lots of discover these correction modes profitable.
The Humane Society warns towards the misuse of shock collars. They will create concern, nervousness, and aggression in your canine and can worsen their undesirable conduct. By no means use shock as a type of punishment. In case you’re questioning whether or not it’s best to use the shock characteristic with these collars, take a look at our in-depth article on shock collars to see the professionals and cons.
Want Different Canine Collars?
The marketplace for varied canine collars is very large. Past shock collars for coaching, I encourage you to see our opinions of different canine collars you could want, together with the very best GPS canine collars, bark collars, sensible collars, light-up collars, and extra. A few of our high picks fulfill a number of collar makes use of.
Why Belief Canine Journal?
During the last 10 years, Sally has researched lots of of various canine collars (customary, coaching, sensible, GPS, shock, and so forth.) in addition to exercise monitoring units. She’s a part of a crew of canine specialists at Canine Journal who’ve over a decade of expertise researching, testing, and writing about the very best and most secure merchandise for our furry mates. She’s a mother to at least one rescue canine, Tiny, and three rescue kitties, Bammy, Lola, and Monk.
